Octavia E. Butler’s novel Kindred, introduces a story that is
slightly different from the other texts we have been reading during this
course. This interestingly this novel deals with the topic of time travel. Dana,
a young African American woman is celebrating her twenty-sixth birthday with
her husband Kevin, when she mysteriously gets transported to another time
period. When she wakes up she is in the south and hears the screams of a young
boy drowning. This young boy is Rufus, the son of Tom Weylin, a plantation
owner.
After realizing that she may be
transported to this time period again, Dana makes it her goal to try to educate
and prevent Rufus from becoming the cruel slave owner his father is. After
hearing Rufus call her a nigger Dana states, “His air of questioning confused
me. Either he really didn’t know what he was saying, or he had a career waiting
in Hollywood. Whichever it was he wasn’t going to go on saying it to me” (25).
This is her first attempt at educating Rufus, but as we continue to see later
her attempts are challenged because of the horrible environment he is being
exposed to. Everything that he knows he has obtained from his parents or from
observations around him. Although Rufus’s young instinctive moral sense gives
Dana hope that he might not grow up to be like his father, his good instincts
prove to be no match for the power he is later given.
When we first are introduced to Rufus he
is a young boy, and despite being constantly bombarded with the ideas that the
color of his skin gives him the authority and superiority over African American
people, he shows Dana that he is still humane and compassionate by trying to
protect her from his parents. This can be seen in one moment in the text when
Dana is reading to Rufus and Margaret continuously attempts to interrupt and
get Dana to leave. To Margaret’s surprise Rufus responds, “‘don’t say nothing!’
Rufus took his head off her lap. ‘Go away and stop bothering me!’” (103). Rufus
choosing Dana over his mother shows the type of bond that they have
established. He seems to demonstrate more respect towards Dana in situations
like this. However, his actions also
show how much his father’s behavior has begun to influence him. Dana describes
her observations,
Rufus turned his head and looked at her.
The expression on his face startled me. For once, the small boy looked like a
smaller replica of his father. His mouth was drawn into a thin straight line
and his were coldly hostile. He spoke quietly now as Weyling sometimes did when
he was angry. ‘You’re making me sick, Mama. Get away from me!’ (104).
Rufus
is slowly transforming into his father and this is one of the moments when Dana
begins to recognize this. He has disrespected his mother because he has seen
his father do the same multiple times. Therefore he has already been
conditioned to think that this type of behavior along with the way slaves are
treated is acceptable. This moment is significant because it shows that despite
Dana’s efforts to educate him, this seems to foreshadow what Rufus’ behavior
will be as an adult. Rufus can’t help
but act this way because it is the only way that he has been taught to act
towards other individuals.
Upon Dana’s
fourth transport to the south, she returns to a completely different Rufus. The
young boy she last saw is has now grown into an adult. She quickly finds out
that he is a changed person. Upon returning she arrives to the scene of a
fight, between Rufus and Alice’s husband Issac. Dana finds out that this fight
is occurring because Rufus raped Alice. Once again we see the effects of his
father’s behavior. Rufus has used his superiority and power to try to get
something that he wanted even if it means he has to use violence to get it.
Dana is shocked by this revelation. She states “I gazed down at him bitterly.
Kevin had been right. I’d been foolish to hope to influence him” (123). It is
during this moment when Dana realizes that her previous efforts to alter this
child’s future were futile. I don’t think Dana was foolish to try to change the
type of person Rufus could turn to. However, it was definitely going to be a
hard task considering that Rufus is surrounded by this negative behavior. He
can’t help but act based on what he has seen and been taught by his father.
As an adult, Rufus succumbs to the
corrupting influence of the authority that is given to him. He is now able to
use what Dana wants; freedom, and Kevin, against her. Knowing that Dana is
desperate to be reunited with Kevin, he fools her and does not send the letters
she has written to her husband. Unbeknownst to her, she patiently tries to wait
for his return and willingly does as she is told. Once Kevin comes back to
rescue Dana, Rufus is determined to get not let her leave the plantation. As
Dana attempt’s to escape, Rufus declares, “‘you’re not leaving!’ he shouted. He
sort of crouched around the gun, clearly on the verge of firing. ‘Damn you, you’re
not leaving me!’” (187). Once again he is using his power and the
threat of violence to try to get what he wants. It seems like he has grown
attached to Dana and fears her abandonment. However, just like Alice I feel
like Rufus is always trying to obtain what he can’t have. He knows that Dana is
not supposed to be in his time period but he is reluctant and selfish to try to
keep her there. He not only tries to manipulate her life but also the lives of
everyone on the plantation. Like a true plantation owner he manages to do this
through the only way he knows, corruption, manipulation, the use of fear and
violence.
It is interesting to see how power can change
someone for the worst. However, I feel like you can’t blame Rufus for the
future he was destined to have. Dana tried to change this but the influence of
his father was far too strong. One thing that I was left wondering was if Dana
would have spent more time on the plantation to teach Rufus while he was
becoming an adult if that could have made a difference? Dana tried to change
him as a child but while she was back in her time Rufus was becoming an adult
and wasn’t there during that time to continue her teachings. So it would have
just been interesting to see if that would have made a difference in any way.
I like Jazmin's question in her final paragraph about whether or not Dana having more of a presence while rufus was becoming an adult would have changed the man he grew in to. I think that this would not have changed Rufus' outcome, because it is important to take in the nature of the society in which he is surrounded. While Dana could try to influence Rufus as a child, she could not take him out of the atmosphere in which he is surrounded by prejudices, racism, and the mistreatment of blacks. Furthermore, the naive and innocence of Rufus as a child is lost as he becomes a man, such as it is lost in many of us when we reach adulthood. Again, this is not something that Dana could change, even if she was present for more of his transition into adulthood. And then the question of whether or not Rufus would want to give up the privileges of being a superior white male in the antebellum south raise another important issue. Rufus would have to have extremely sound morals, independently of Dana, to be the son of a white slave owner, and then deny this life himself, because he knows it is wrong.
ReplyDeleteI agree that when Dana tried to change Rufus and educate him her intention were in the right place but I think that the time periods between her visits to Rufus were the problem. Many times throughout the book it is stated that Rufus seemed better when Dana was around and able to influence Rufus. But the trouble was when she wasn’t there. Tom Weylin and the lifestyle of slavery that the family was embedded in had much more of an impact on their lives in shaping them as people than Dana did. It may have helped if Rufus could have been taken back to the future with Dana at some point to experience another time and life that was completely different than the farm, but Rufus never was able to know any other life except for the cruel institution of slavery. I think that this may have made a huge difference in Rufus’ life and may have changed how he grew up and the actions that he made
ReplyDelete